Best Fly Fishing in Pennsylvania

A person stands in a river, casting a fly fishing rod against a backdrop of lush greenery in Pennsylvania.
Shaman Mountain is reader-supported. We may earn a small commission on certain links, at no additional cost to you. Learn more.

Pennsylvania offers a diverse range of fly fishing experiences, with its abundant waterways and a variety of fish species. The state is renowned for its exceptional trout fishing opportunities, and as you explore what Pennsylvania has to offer, you’ll understand why. From the famous trout-filled waters of Penns Creek to the challenging conditions of winter fly fishing at Young Womans Creek, there’s something to cater to the preferences of anglers at all skill levels.

Spring Creek

When you’re seeking some of the finest fly fishing opportunities in Pennsylvania, Spring Creek should top your list. Located in central Pennsylvania, it is celebrated for its abundant and sizeable wild brown trout population. What once was a polluted waterway, Spring Creek has undergone significant conservation efforts transforming it into a remarkable destination for anglers.

Fly Fishing Spots

  • Fisherman’s Paradise: Accessible and well-known, offering ample opportunities for a successful catch.
  • Benner Spring Hatchery: Provides a different setting with the chance to catch both stocked and wild trout.

Hatches and Flies

  • Blue-Winged Olives (BWOs): Effective during the spring and fall seasons.
  • Sulphurs: Ideal in late spring.
  • Caddis: Useful throughout the summer months.

Regulations and Tips

  • Catch and Release: Certain sections of Spring Creek are designated catch and release only.
  • Respect Private Land: Always be mindful that parts of Spring Creek run through private property.

Before you embark on your Spring Creek fishing adventure, research the specific sections and regulations and plan your visit during peak hatching periods to increase your chances of a successful day on the water. For more detailed information, visit DIY Guide to Fly Fishing Spring Creek in Pennsylvania and Fly Fishing Spring Creek, An Angler’s Guide. These guides offer comprehensive insights into making the most of your fly fishing experience in one of Pennsylvania’s top-rated trout streams.

Penns Creek

Location and Access
Penns Creek is a renowned fly-fishing destination in North-Central Pennsylvania. It originates at Penns Cave, wending through mountains and farmland to join the Susquehanna River. Accessing certain parts of the stream often requires a hike, promising both solitude and a rich fishing experience.

Gear Recommendations
When you’re targeting the abundant trout of Penns Creek, your gear matters. A versatile choice is a 9-foot 5-wt fly rod with floating line, optimum for dry flies and small nymphs. Heavier nymphs and streamers may be better served by a 6-wt with a sink tip fly line. Standard leaders are tapered, 9-foot with tippet sizes ranging from 3X to 6X to match your flies.

Flies and Hatches
Penns Creek is celebrated for its remarkable hatches, making it essential that you have the right flies. Staples for this stream include patterns that imitate the local aquatic insect life, especially during the Slate and Green Drake hatches. Frequent visits to nearby fly shops for the latest hatch information can greatly improve your chances of success.

Current Conditions
Before planning your trip, check the latest fishing reports for stream conditions, which can impact your strategy on the water. As of the latest update, conditions on Penns Creek appear favorable, with normal water levels contributing to good fishing opportunities.

Yellow Breeches Creek

Yellow Breeches Creek is a renowned fly fishing destination in south-central Pennsylvania, flowing into the Susquehanna River. Your fishing experience here will be enriched by the creek’s mix of limestone spring water and freestone characteristics, offering diverse aquatic habitats.

Noteworthy Hatches:

  • Spring: The season brings prolific hatches, with aquatic insects emerging in abundance.
  • Mid-Summer: Look out for the unique white fly hatch, an event that local and visiting anglers eagerly anticipate.

Fishing Tips:

  • Opt for wade fishing to navigate the creek’s accessible stretches.
  • Equip yourself with Perfect Flies, which are highly regarded among enthusiasts for their effectiveness on this water.

When fishing Yellow Breeches Creek, respect the catch and release areas, contributing to the conservation of this precious fishery. If you witness any illegal fishing activities, you’re encouraged to report them to maintain the integrity of the creek.

Seasons to Visit:

  • March through August: Peak fly fishing season
  • Note: The Creek remains a viable fishing option year-round, depending on weather and water conditions.

For up-to-date fishing reports and conditions, check Yellow Breeches Creek | PA Fly Fishing Reports & Conditions – Orvis. Whether you are an experienced angler or new to fly fishing, Yellow Breeches Creek promises a rewarding experience amidst Pennsylvania’s scenic landscapes.

Fishing Creek

The sun sets over a serene creek, surrounded by lush greenery. A fly fisherman casts their line, creating ripples in the water as they search for the perfect catch

Fishing Creek, prominently known for its trout-rich waters, is a gem tucked away in the heart of Pennsylvania. At Big Fishing Creek, you’ll discover a variety of flies that are effective in these waters, like the Cream Variant and Elk Wing Caddis. These local favorites are sure to enhance your angling experience.

Recommended Fly Assortment:

  • Dry Flies: Cream Variant (#12-14), Elk Wing Caddis (#12-18)
  • Nymphs: Bead Head Stonefly (#6-10), Tunghead Pheasant Tail Jig (#12-18)
  • Streamers: GD SculpSnack (#6-12)

In Northeast Pennsylvania, another Fishing Creek flows through Columbia County, contributing as a tributary to the Susquehanna River. This historic place, first settled around 8000 BCE, offers a unique fly fishing experience detailed in this guide.

Seasonal Highlights:

  • Spring/Summer: Optimal for dry flies and nymphs.
  • Fall: Brown trout spawning period; low crowds.
  • Winter: Opportunity to catch trout on midge imitations.

For your gear, consider a fly line weight between 4 and 6. Your leader setup should vary with the technique:

  • Dry fly: 9 to 12 ft., 5 or 6X
  • Nymphing: 7½ ft., 3 or 4X
  • Streamers: 0-2X

A well-equipped tackle box and familiarity with the local hatches can significantly enhance your fishing endeavors on Fishing Creek. Remember, every season brings about different fishing conditions, so plan your trip accordingly for the best outcome.

Little Juniata River

When you set out for a day of fly fishing in Pennsylvania, the Little Juniata River should be at the top of your list. Often referred to as the ‘Little J’, this tributary of the Juniata River flows through Central Pennsylvania and is known for its outstanding trout fishing.

The river supports a healthy population of brown trout and is recognized for its remarkable wild trout fishery. Here are some tips and information to get you started:

  • Fly Rod: A 9-foot 5-wt fly rod with floating line is ideal for the Little Juniata. It gives you the versatility to handle a variety of flies, from dry flies to small nymphs.
  • Fly Selection: Depending on the season, your fly box should include a range of dry flies, nymphs, and streamers to match the hatches occurring on the river.
SeasonSuggested Flies
SpringBlue-Winged Olives, Grannom Caddis
SummerSulphurs, Terrestrials
FallStreamers for larger trout
WinterMidges, Small Nymphs
  • Water Levels: The river can vary significantly in flow. Always check the current conditions before your trip. High water levels may make wading challenging.

Keep in mind that a Pennsylvania fishing license is required, along with a trout stamp, to fish the Little Juniata. Your compliance with local fishing regulations not only keeps you legal but also helps to sustain the fishery for years to come.

Big Spring Creek

When you explore the clear waters of Big Spring Creek, you’ll find yourself immersed in a five-mile stretch renowned for its fly fishing opportunities. Nestled in Cumberland County, this tributary of Conodoguinet Creek is fed by smaller streams, resulting in stable water conditions ideal for a thriving trout population.

What to Expect:

  • Prime Location: The creek emerges near U.S. Route 11, about eight miles northeast of Shippensburg, before joining Conodoguinet Creek near Newville.
  • Trout Abundance: You’ll discover that Big Spring Creek offers an impressive density of brook trout, with estimates of up to 350 pounds per acre. It’s not uncommon to encounter brook trout stretching up to 20 inches.

Fishing Tips:

  • Gear Recommendation: Opt for light to medium tackle, and consider dry flies or nymphs to entice the local trout population.
  • Best Time of Year to Visit: Spring and fall are particularly productive seasons for fly fishing here, thanks to optimal water temperatures.

With conservation efforts playing an integral role in preserving this fishery, Big Spring Creek remains a premier destination for anglers seeking both natural beauty and the thrill of catching large and healthy trout. Whether you’re a seasoned fly fisher or just dipping your toes into the sport, a visit to Big Spring Creek in Pennsylvania is sure to be a memorable experience.

Letort Spring Run

Letort Spring Run is a renowned limestone stream located in South-Central Pennsylvania, known for its history and role in developing fly fishing techniques. The stream offers a challenging but rewarding experience, as the clear waters and educated trout require stealth and finesse.

Access Points:

  • Letort Spring Park: Easy entry to the lower reaches.
  • Marinaro’s Meadow: Historically significant spot with more challenging fishing conditions.

Advice for Anglers:

  • Approach quietly and keep a low profile to avoid spooking the fish.
  • Use subtle fly patterns; the local trout are known for being very selective.
MonthSuggested Fly Patterns
January-MarchMidges and Little Blue-Winged Olives
April-JuneCaddis and Sulphurs
July-AugustTerrestrials, such as Ants and Beetles
SeptemberLate Season Mayflies
October-DecemberStreamers and Nymphs for larger trout

When you fish the Letort Spring Run, you’re following in the footsteps of fly fishing legends. Respect for the environment and catch-and-release practices help preserve this special place. Knowledgeable anglers often recommend using a Perfect Fly Supreme Four, Superb Five, or Ultimate Six fly rod for the best experience.

Before heading out, check the latest fishing reports to get up-to-date information on stream conditions and hatching activity. Remember, fishing near the warmer spring water can be particularly fruitful during colder months.

By respecting the stream’s etiquette and history, your time at Letort Spring Run could be the fly fishing trip of a lifetime.

Allegheny River

The Allegheny River boasts a prominent reputation among fly fishing enthusiasts in Pennsylvania. Spanning roughly 325 miles, this river not only offers scenic beauty but also a variety of challenged targets for your fly fishing ambition. Notably, the Allegheny River is accessible from both Pennsylvania and New York, giving you ample opportunities to find your perfect spot.

Begin your journey in the wooded hills, where the river provides a serene backdrop for casting lines. This guide will give you an in-depth understanding of the river’s characteristics. The Allegheny River culminates in Pittsburgh, joining the Monongahela River to form the Ohio River, offering diverse fishing experiences along its course.

Here’s what you should know about the Allegheny River:

  • Fish Species: Home to the elusive muskie, the river also hosts other species like trout and smallmouth bass. Your fly fishing skills are sure to be tested here.
  • Best Times: Aim for springtime, when the water levels are generally favorable. However, the river can be fished throughout the general Pennsylvania trout season.
  • Locations: Seek out areas with wooded hillsides and small towns along the banks for a serene fly fishing experience.

When packing your gear, ensure you’re prepared for the diverse conditions along the river. Remember to respect the local regulations and habitats to preserve this gem for future generations of fly fishers.

Oil Creek

When you’re looking to fly fish in Pennsylvania, Oil Creek should be high on your list of destinations. Oil Creek flows through Venango and Crawford counties and becomes a 46.7-mile-long tributary of the Allegheny River. It boasts a wide stream, in places reaching nearly 100 feet across, and covers a substantial 319-square-mile drainage area.

  • Location: Oil Creek begins at Canadohita Lake in Northwestern Pennsylvania and spans approximately thirty miles.
  • Trout Population: There is a healthy population of trout in the stream, with various sections offering diverse fishing experiences.

You’ll find two Delayed Harvest Areas that tend to be popular among anglers, but they might not be the best spots in the creek. The uppermost section of Oil Creek offers a smaller stream environment, which can provide a different fishing experience.

For the best fishing opportunities, focus on the section downstream from Titusville. There, you can access the creek easily thanks to numerous bridges and pull-offs along State Routes and other roads. It’s recommended to visit during the appropriate fishing season and keep up to date with the local fishing reports. This ensures you’re informed about the current conditions and any specific fly patterns that might be effective.

Here are some additional tips for your fly fishing adventure on Oil Creek:

  • Fly Selection: Be mindful of the hatches and select your flies accordingly.
  • Gear: Standard fly fishing gear suffices, with strike indicators and nymphing methods being particularly effective.

For more detailed insights and local knowledge on fly fishing this picturesque Pennsylvania stream, consider exploring resources such as DIY Guide to Fly Fishing Oil Creek in Northwest Pennsylvania and Fly Fishing on the Oil Creek Pennsylvania. This valuable information can enhance your fishing experience on Oil Creek.

Clarion River

When you’re seeking some of the finest fly fishing spots in Pennsylvania, the Clarion River deserves your attention. Originating in Elk County, this tributary of the Allegheny River offers you a diverse fishing experience amidst scenic vistas.

Seasonal Fishing Tips:

  • Spring: Enjoy abundant aquatic insect hatches for a vibrant fly fishing experience.
  • Summer: The main stem slows, but the East Branch stays cool for better fishing conditions.
  • Fall: Arguably the best season for sizable brown trout due to spawning activities.

What You’ll Catch:

  • Brown trout
  • Rainbow trout
  • Brook Trout
  • Smallmouth bass

To maximize your day on the river, stay informed about current conditions by checking fly fishing reports for the Clarion River. Equip yourself with the top producing flies and gear recommendations to increase your chances of a successful catch.

Fly fishing on the Clarion River is recognized for its world-class trout and smallmouth bass fishing, often touted as a hidden gem in the state. You can find further insights into what makes this river an excellent fishing locale and learn about its underrated status among Eastern U.S. fisheries here.

For those who prefer visual learning, a useful resource is a guide that showcases fly fishing on the Clarion River through engaging footage, providing a glimpse of what to expect during your fishing adventure.

Remember, every fishing trip is unique, but with the natural beauty and abundance of fish, the Clarion River might just become your go-to fly fishing destination in Pennsylvania.

Related Posts:

A serene river winds through lush forest, with a mountain backdrop. A lone fly fisherman casts his line into the clear water, surrounded by vibrant foliage

Best Fly Fishing in Oregon

Oregon is renowned for its diverse and prolific fly fishing destinations, offering some of the most rewarding experiences for anglers. From the serene banks of

A serene picnic spot in Pennsylvania, nestled among towering trees and beside a tranquil stream. A checkered blanket is spread out on the lush green grass, with a wicker basket and a bouquet of wildflowers sitting nearby

Best Picnic Spots in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania, a state brimming with lush forests, rolling hills, and meandering rivers, offers a cornucopia of picturesque spots perfect for spreading out a blanket and

Small boat on a lake in Pennsylvania.

Best Boating in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania, a state renowned for its diverse landscapes, is a haven for boating enthusiasts seeking the best aquatic experiences. From expansive lakes to winding rivers,